Saturday, April 30, 2011

CURATOR'S STATEMENT

            In this curatorial project, I am looking at artwork that focuses on the body, but more specifically, on images of child bodies, and how they relate to our understandings of childhood. This exhibit explores how representations of children in our contemporary visual culture of fine art inform our conceptual understanding of children and childhood. How do images of the child affect our relationship to the child and image of the child? How do contemporary artists explore this concept in their artworks, and what are they telling us about children? The photographs in this exhibit explore probe the understanding of the social construction of childhood, attempting to re-write or re-construct this narrative of the stereotypical understanding of childhood.

My experience of our culture is that it is highly constructed by the influence of media. We are constantly saturated with hundreds of images daily, which seems to be out of our control, as we are conditioned to think and behave in certain ways. Even more intriguing, is that this applies to realms of our culture that we think are natural. In this case, I believe that the concept of childhood is an entirely constructed entity, created by the spreading idea of a universal child and childhood, which is predictable and programmed to act and occur in specific developmental ways. More specifically, what I have been finding as a student of art education is that most people find children to be locked in this limited space of innocence and naivety, when in fact children are not all predictable, and childhood is not a concept that can be defined and categorized universally into neat and tidy folds. The growth and development of children is erratic and perpetually becoming, not stable and predictable. What I find interesting now is the image of the child that our society has perpetuated, and what we have come to construct as being childhood. Mainly, the child is an innocent being that needs to be protected and controlled, and childhood is a time of happiness, ingenuous curiosity, and timelessness.

            Anna Gaskell’s narrative portraits, Untitled 36 (Wonder) (1996) and Hunt (2008), allow the child’s body to be hung in time and space; showing the child’s lack of control over their own stories because of adult shaping. Similarly, Polixeni Papapetrou’s portrait The Wave Counter (2011) shows a child dressed in the costume of an aging adult. The child’s body is seen hunching, leaning into the wind, as if bracing time itself.

Tracey Moffatt uses her own life as a narrative, calling forth her personal memories in Scarred for Life II (1987), allowing the viewer a look into a more real child’s life, who is strained by the struggles of family life, just as Sally Mann depicts her own child in Fallen Child (1989), giving us a view of the child as one with Earth; an interesting new spin on the idea of childhood. Catherine Opie also uses a portrait of her child, in Oliver Wears a Tutu (2004), challenging the viewers idea of gender appropriate behavior.

Other artist’s, like Vee Speers, Loretta Lux, Pat Brassington, and Deborah Paauwe take a more chilling approach, with photographs of children that are almost haunting. Speers Untitled #32, from The birthday Party Series (2011) comments on the contradicting ideal of childhood s a happy time, as the child depicted stares intently at the viewer, with no expression of happiness. Lux’s portrait of Isabella (2000) is crafted to be foreboding in an inadvertent way. The head of Isabella is enlarged and her skin glazed over like a porcelain doll, with blue eyes open and ominous; the innocence in the portrait is so over exaggerated it is hauntingly beautiful. Brassington’s Space for Dreams #4 (2005) on the other hand has no particular portrait to it, as the face is turned away, evoking the ambiguity of both the body and environment. Similarly, Deborah Paauwe’s photograph Autumn Dusk (2004) presents an ambiguous portrait, but clearly presents a contradictory look at the innocence of child and adolescent, with a purposefully posed figure wearing red make-up. 

Nicola Loder takes a similar yet different approach, by directly representing the child as a powerful being, through 175 portraits aligned and uniform in a grid, just as Rineke Dijkstra provides the viewer with a photograph of an upright child who is captured as fully aware and competent, even in the midst of “playing”.


Sally Mann : "Fallen Child" (1989)

Fallen Child
Sally Mann
1989
Photograph/Gelatin silver enlargement print
18 3/4 x 23 in

(image from The Guggenheim)

I chose this image to show first, because I feel that it is least similar to those below. The image here by Sally Mann reminds me of the idea that children are innocent, universal, and natural beings. I feel that many adults believe that childhood is a time of innocence and purity, and have created misgivings about the capabilities of children. While almost all of Sally Mann’s portraits of her children provide us with a perspective of childhood that is contrary to what our culture has created, in that they show children as capable of moving and being in adult ways, I feel this one is both similar and dissimilar. The child here (Mann’s daughter) is sprawled across the ground, appearing as almost one with Earth, with the outer edges of the photograph blurred and her tiny body sprinkled with grass. So in one sense, the image conforms to the constructed ideal of child as pure and innocent, having no influence by adults, but on the other hand, it could be a disruptive view, because it could just as easily be representing the fact that this is a myth; that this child, though fitting in her landscape, will not continue to grow in this pure a way. As  Ted Mann puts it on the the Guggenheim Museum online collection however, "Mann's photographs of her children are at once specific and universal", therefore conforming to the idea I do not agree with; that childhood is a universal developmental stage which is predictable (Guggenheim). However, the image speaks in multiple ways. At the same time, Mann has said, "We are spinning a story of what it is to grow up. It is a complicated story and sometimes we try to take on the grand themes—anger, love, death, sensuality, and beauty" showing me that she does understand that the idea of childhood is constructed by the adult world (Guggenheim).

Exhibitions:  Online Collection at The Guggenheim.
Artist Biography:  Available at The GuggenheimPBS and Edwynn Houk Gallery

Anna Gaskell : "Hunt" (2008)

Hunt
Anna Gaskell
(2008)
Photograph (C-print)
20 x 24 in

(image from artnet)

Creating a nice contrast and transition from the image above of the child that is one with Earth, this image by Anna Gaskell appears to me as the quintessential image of the child as constructed by the adult world. Here she stands upright, feet on top of Earth, progressively growing into the adult world. The small child with bright orange hunting gear is positioned into an adult posture, which we associate with holding a gun. The violence, though not pictured through an actual image of a gun, is obvious to the viewer because of the blatant social cues - namely, the clothing and posture we associate with hunting. Gaskell creates the relationship between adult and child through the adult hand that braces the child’s shoulder, encouraging her and constructing her movements and actions, just like the metaphorical adult hands that mold the idea of the universal child and childhood. Though there is little work online written about this piece, I think it strongly contrasts the Sally Mann piece above, as this child is one who is separated from Earth, seemingly transitioned or transitioning into the adult world which doesn't always mesh so purely with nature. I think there is also something to be said for the downward slope of the horizon line. The frame dynamics here make the picture seem correct, as the eye follows the lines gentle, but we know that the horizon should be straight. The declining horizon line the points to the figures hips,  figuratively splitting her body in half.

Artist Biography: Available at The Guggenheim


Anna Gaskell : "Untitled #6 (wonder)" (1996)

Untitled #6 (wonder)
Anna Gaskell
(1996)
Photograph/Chromogenic print
19 x 23 1/4 in

(image from The Guggenheim)

Anna Gaskell strikes again in this image, continuing on the theme of narrative photography, through which she often captures the image of the constructed fairytale-like child in theatrical scenes that reference popular culture created by adults, for children. This image pretty blatantly references Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland, with the apparently pre-adolescent girl’s dress mirroring the popular character’s outfit. The body of the child is captured in mid air; her head severed by the harshness of the frame. The child here is literally frozen in space and time, hung by the controls of something beyond herself, and missing her head to sort things out. The body seems to have no control over its suspension, as the upright arms seem to be wavering cautiously, with fingers raising slightly. The position of the female body itself in the frame correlates to the idea that children have no control over their bodies, or lives, fitting with the idea of childhood as a social construction by adults. Children are constructed by the adult world, and are simply floating through it, while trying to maintain their ideas about their own, separate world which we have created to be known as childhood; this innocent, pure place that adults have categorized, theorized, and dissected into specific stages of development and predictable lifestyles.
 When you take into consideration the Alice in Wonderland reference, the figure that is so lost in space begins to seem stuck in-between realities, just as Alice was stuck between her understandings of whether or not the things happening to her were indeed fractions of reality. However, the figure's ambiguity and strange position leaves the viewer wondering how this narrative ends.

Artist Biography:  Available at The Guggenheim
Writing on Photograph:  The Guggenheim and Utata
Exhibitions:  Role Models: Feminine Identity in Contemporary American Photography (2008-2009)


Polixeni Papapetrou : "The Wave counter" (2011)

The Wave counter
Polixeni Papapetrou
(2011)
Pigment ink print
105 cm x 105 cm

(image from Polixeni Papapetrou's Website

I found this quote by Papapetrou regarding her work on child photography, which I find to be quintessential to understanding her work:

"I started making pictures about childhood because I wanted to express ideas about our culture that are best portrayed through the symbol of the child, but more importantly, I am fascinated by the world of childhood. I am conscious that my work on the one hand, takes the viewer into the realms of fantasy and story telling, but on the other hand, it challenges our expectations regarding the portrayal of childhood in photography" (NYMPHOTO, 2008)

In this piece, the child’s face is covered, wearing a mask too large for his or her head that gives them the appearance of an aging man. The walker, and the posture of the child, seemingly leaning into the wind that blows their clothes to the right, gives me this sensation of the child being far away in thought. It feels as though the child has stepped into the shows of the adult world, and is looking afar to the worlds that are so separated by time. The body of the figure is essential to the photograph; the small frame of the child which is leaning forward into the wind, but also almost taking in the posture of a crippling adult, reminds the viewer of the separation between the worlds of adulthood and childhood. Although at the same time, it seems that the costume gives the child the ability to waver between adult and child worlds. It reminds me of the work above by Anna Gaskell, in that the child appears to be living between realities, fluidly coming back and forth.  I like that the photograph challenges these well-known ideals of childhood, being that the almost worldwide cultural idea of childhood includes the innocence and naivety of childhood. This child blows that out image out of the water, appearing thoughtful and pensive in this world of adultness.

Artist Biography: Foley Gallery
ExhibitionsPolixeni Papapetrou's Website, 2011 Tales from Elsewhere, Australian Centre for Photography, Sydney
References: NYMPHOTO (2008)


Tracey Moffatt : "Scarred for Life II (always the sheep)" (1987)

Scarred for Life II (always the sheep)
Tracey Moffatt
(1987)
Off-set Lithograph
35 1/2 x 27 1/2 in


This image reminds the viewer of the struggle of the child who is influenced and molded by their family and society. The small text under the image as created by Moffatt reads, "the smallest boy in class had to be the sheep every night in the production of Waltzing Matilda.” Inspired by Moffatt's own memories of childhood insecurities crafted by family strife, the artist is giving the viewer a perspective on childhood that lies outside of the perfect and ideal story. This story holds a child with emotional obstacles that are not easily overcome, nor fully or adequately described by the caption. Apparently, "Scarred for life I’ and ‘II’ are printed on thin off-white paper akin to scaled up pages from ‘Life’ magazine," and the captions are meant to mock the captions seen in Time Magazine that often seem so distant from the truth (2007).

The photograph also comments on power relations, in that the peers of the young boy in the foreground of the image overpower him because of his size. The boy dressed as a sheep has a story that is not characterized by fun the playfulness that we think most children encounter in life. He is instead seen with an odd expression: seemingly distressed and perturbed. Interestingly enough, he also seems to be of Asian race, which may play into the idea of racial discrimination that many children often face as they grow up. Concluding, the boy to his left seems dominant, staring intently at the camera as if to watch what might be going on, as the two girls on the right follow his commanding eyesight, commenting on the stereotypical role of female as dependant and separate from the male.

Artist Biography: Rena Bransten Gallery and Tate Museum
Exhibitions: Scarred For Life (1994)
References: (2007) Art Gallery of New South Wales Photography Collection Handbook. retrieved from.


Catherine Opie : "Oliver in a Tutu" (2004)

Oliver in a Tutu
Catherine Opie
(2004)
Photograph

(image from ArtInfo)

This image by Catherine Opie calls some attention to the constructed ideals of gender, as well as the construction of family community. The child here is at play with two sets of constructed gender ideals. At first, the viewer may associate the child with the female gender, because of the stereotypically portrayed female garments; namely, the tiara, jewelry, and tutu. However, when the viewer is then drawn in and takes another look, the image of the child and its gender becomes more ambiguous, and the uncertainty grows. The facial features of the child do not lead the viewer on a path of easily catagorizable gender, and calls attention to our misgivings about what defines male and female, in this case in children. What adults have constructed as being easily identifiable signs of female gender (tutu, tiara, pink), have been displaced by just the opposite, the child’s short hair, t-shirt and an ambiguous face, all of which we usually define as being male.

In addition to the play on gender, the image has a sense of hominess, being that the child here, Oliver, is Opie’s own son, who seems to be captured candidly. It brings a sense of community forth, in that "The community here is Opie’s own family" (Green, 2006). The candid quality of the photo creates the intimacy that is both inviting and perplexing at once. The eye is gently guided around Oliver’s surroundings, form the inside with a pink glow from Oliver’s tutu to the contrasting cool colors outside.

Artist Biography: Available at The Guggenheim.
References: Green, T. (2006). Aquisition: Opie @ Guggenheim. retrieved from.




Vee Speers : Untitled #32, The birthday Party Series

Untitled #32, The birthday Party Series
Vee Speers
(2011)
Photograph


Vee Speers work moves us into the more chilling depictions of childhood. This photo represents one of many “childhood dreams”, linked to an imaginary birthday party, with the game of dress-up lingering at play. The girl pictured has one story of many, yet also represents a greater story of the memories of childhood. As she back, her body sandwiched by the wall and the dolls that she embraces, and her knees seem interlocked in a coy manner. Her body position seems shy, while her facial expression is intense. Through this portrait, Speers is commenting on the “side of childhood that is not carefree or clichéd” (Speers, 2011). While the girl here is seemingly displaying little through her facial expression, besides leaving the viewer with a blank stare and pursed lips, she is obviously contradicting the image of the happy child that most people associate with childhood. Although her expression seems blank, it is in fact simply full of emotions that we are not used to being portrayed by children. We are not typically accustomed to the child’s capability to express a narrative other than the ideal. I think Speers is trying to portray a more common but un-recognized story of a child; one that has the ability to express emotions like the one here, that isn’t tied to the stereotypical image of the child we all 'know and love'. It appears: "Speers'... fascination with the trickery of appearance, and the power of masks, costumes and outward signals from inner worlds" is deeply set within this photograph (Casper, 2011). I even think that the curled hair and covered chest that would be otherwise exposed explore a sexual theme. The child is obviously capable of emotions and expressions that reach beyond the mundane image of the child society has created, and I sort of think a sexual gaze is at play here as well, though not in the perverted sense of being inviting; but that the child is aware of her body and expressions.


Artist Biography: Vee Speers Website
Exhibitions: The Birthday Party, Nordic Light International Festival of Photography (2011), The Birthday Party (2010)
References: Casper, J. (2011) The Birthday Party. Lens Culture. Retrieved From.



Loretta Lux : "Isabella" (2000)

Isabella
Loretta Lux
(2000)
Ilfochrome Print
14 15/16 x 14 15/16 in


Loretta Lux is infamous for her images of children that at first glance seem jarringly pure, but become more and more estranged as the viewer dwells. It reminds me of Speers work because both of the children have these perfect faces with striking expressions. Commenting on the sheer beauty of the images, Tedd Mann from the Guggenheim tells us, “as benign as they may initially seem, however, the doll-like figures are strangely unsettling” (Mann). Here, the head of Isabella seems unfit for her frame, and her skin seems too porcelain to be real, with her huge blue eyes open and ominous, typical features of Lux’s child portraits. The whole coloring and appearance make the child appear like a doll; challenging the idea that all children are universal, by showing us how chilling that idea is. The innocence in the portrait is so over exaggerated it is haunting; reminding the viewer again, how unnatural this sort of purity and innocence is, and how that purity it is not real, but a constructed idea, just as this portrait is constructed through Lux's photographic technique. "Lux's children are blank, at best lost in a daydream, at worst more remote than the most withdrawn real-world child" (Hart, 2005). However, as much as I speculate about the meaning of this image, Lux is actually known for being ambiguous about the particular meanings behind her images, but we know "the images... are less about the subjects than they are a metaphor for the idea of childhood" (Sayre, 2006). So my take on this is that the metaphor of childhood that is at play in this image comments on the eeriness of the present ideal that children are perfectly predictable and naïve.

Artist Biography: Available at Loretta Lux and The Guggenheim
References: Hart, R. (2005). In Focus. American Photo, Vol. XVI (3). Retrieved from.
Mann, T. The Guggenheim.
Sayre, C. (2006). Lens Crafters. Time Magazine. Retrieved from.

Pat Brassington : "Space for Dreams #4" (2009)

Space for Dreams #4
Pat Brassington
(2009)
Pigment Print
74 x 58cm

(image from Stills Gallery)

The image above by Pat Brassington reminds me of how most adults have helped perpetuated the idea that childhood is a time for dreaming and becoming. The ambiguous pink space here holds a child who is defying gravity, twisting her body as if to perhaps jump and spin. The movement and lack of shadow under the child’s body is surrealist, and calls attention to a deeper meaning, though I can’t say I know for sure what that is. I can assume that the image represents childhood as this space for dreaming and becoming, though the ambiguity of the photo adds to the interest, as the viewer is left waiting for something more. The hidden face and plain clothing add to the anonymity of the figure, though we can tell it is a child’s body, which leads me to believe that Brassington is touching on the idea of childhood dreams and what spaces and times are appropriate for those, as decided by the adult world. "Brassington blurs the boundaries of the real and imagined, stripping photography of its authority, bestowing it instead with the logic of dream or fantasy" (Stills Gallery). The surrealism calls attention to the universal dream of childhood playfulness and returning to that time that most associate with being a carefree time. I think the image also calls to the qualities of Papapetrou's The Wave Counter, because they both have this fantastical quality about them, involving this space between spaces.

Artist Biography: Available at Stills Gallery.
ReferencesStills Gallery


Nicola Loder : "Child 1-175: a nostalgia for the present" (1996)

Child 1-175: a nostalgia for the present
Nicola Loder
(1996)
175 Silver Gelatin Prints

(image from Nicola Loder)

“Loder’s subjects undermined the myth that childhood comprises the “best years of our life’” (Hold, 1996). Said powerfully, Loder’s work in Child 1-175 gives us a taste of the child that breaches that myth; the child who is strong, powerful, experienced, and knowing. The tight portraits of these children integrated within the grid-like frame repeatedly challenge the viewer’s ideal of children. "The sheer repetition of the images in the installation gives the children as a unit menacing power" (Marsh, 2000). The images let us peer into the door of the adult perception of childhood, while proving to us that children cannot be predicted and thought of as a whole, though they are united in that respect. “Her strong character portraits suggest levels of knowledge, torment, ritual, self-possession, humor, and pathos that often go unacknowledged by adults” (Hold, 1996). The images, which are shot from below, put the child’s body (head) in a position above the viewers, showing Loder’s respect for the children; “close investigation reveals the artist’s respect for her subjects, who are shot mostly from below in thoughtful or rapt poses… lost in thought or emotion, inaccessible to us or challenging us” (Freiberg, 1996). These countless representations of children challenge the slighted view of children as universal and naïve that we see often today. "By grouping 175 such images together, she [Loder] created a metaphor for the elaborate and restrictive social structure of childhood, within each individual must find a place" (Hold, 1996).

Artist Biography: Available at Nicola Loder
Exhibitions: Telling Tales: The Child in Contemporary Photography.
 Rapport: 8 artists from Singapore and Australia.
References: Hold, H. (1996). Nicola Loder. Issue #4 (p96). Retrieved from.
Freiberg, F. (1996). Photo Opportunities is St Kilda. Visual arts. Retrieved from.
Marsh, A. (2000). Telling Tales: The child in Contemporary Photography. Retrieved from.

Deborah Paauwe : "Autumn Dusk" (2005)

Autumn Dusk
Deborah Paauwe
(2004)
type C photographs

(image from Deborah Paauwe)

I love this work by Deborah Paauwe because I think it directly challenges the idea of children as innocent and naïve. It also takes a step further in the exhibit, by introducing this exhibit into the time of pre-adolescence, by commenting on the restraints and capability of this type of child as defined by adult perception. The red clothing on the body of what we assume to be a pre- or adolescent girl, and the red and black face paint help the viewer associate the image with something demonic or otherworldly. Since it is adults who often construct and place this idea of the innocent child on the lives of children, and expect that idea to be fulfilled in encountering all children, the image of something other than that ideal is sure to shock the viewer. This image, with its anonymous body and purposeful pose and expression, lead the viewer to believe that the adolescent girl is all-knowing. She has full control over her life and actions, and her story is not defined by the adult world or adult perception of her capabilities. The figure is deliberate with her pose, as she seems to be crossing her arms mockingly, and tilting her head to observe the viewers reaction to her planned action. The crossing of the arms and tilt of the head also references this idea of an angel without wings, or perhaps a body consumed in a morgue (Foster, 2004). She seems mockingly aware of her body parts, and she shows that our understanding of childhood, while created by adults, is also created by children, in that children live in worlds we can almost never remember how to understand.

Artist Biography: Available at Deborah Paauwe and Art Statements and Sutton Gallery
References: Foster, A. (2004) Dark Fables. Retrieved From.

Rineke Dijkstra : "Parque de la Ciudadela, Barcelona" (2005)



Parque de la Ciudadela, Barcelona


Rineke Dijkstra
(2005)
C-Print
75.5 X 94 CM


Dijkstra’s Park portraits all feature people stopped amid their play at parks arund the world, and I think think one calls our attention to the child's awareness of the adult world. This image seems empowering, just as the last two I showed by Paauwe and Loder. Here, this young child is halted on her scooter in Barcelona to be photographed in the center frame. Her body is tightly upright, her posture holding a certain kind of demeanor, as she stares intently at the camera, through the viewer. I ended with this image because although the child is portrayed playing, she seems to be aware of the viewer's presence, and in control of her life. The way her body is positioned atop her perfectly balanced scooter makes me feel as though she capable, not in need of adult control; it is a very empowering photograph.

Artist Biography: Available at the Marian Goodman Gallery and ArtNet.